top of page
04-09-21-08-34-54_hu.logo.web.png
Writer's pictureDK Marley

US and British Intervention in Russia after WWI - an Editorial Review of "Commissar: A Novel of Civil War Russia"



Book Blurb:


After the 1917 revolution, Russia is teetering on the brink of civil war. When the Soviet head of state Lenin is shot by an assassin, CHEKA agent Anna Sokolova is tasked with hunting down British spy Sidney Reilly who set in motion an audacious plot to alter the course of Russian history. Meanwhile, in New York, an American WWI veteran William Arden sets sail on a mission to Russia that is not what it appears to be, and the true purpose of which even he may not yet fully comprehend. Their paths cross in Petrograd, and they become unlikely allies. As a bloody conflict ignites throughout Russia, Anna’s loyalties are tested. Can she save her country and not lose herself in the process?


Based on historical events, Commissar is a gripping spy thriller about the little-known period of US and British intervention in the Russian Civil War (1918-22).


Book Buy Link: https://geni.us/DqZ7M


Author Bio:



D.V. Chernov is an award-winning author of historical and crime fiction. His debut novel Commissar was named Finalist for the prestigious Hemingway International Book Award. D.V. Chernov was born in Omsk, Russia and grew up in the Soviet Union during the final decades of the Cold War before immigrating to the U.S. in 1991. After building a career in the high-tech industry, he decided to follow his long-time dream of writing his first novel. When not writing, D.V. Chernov enjoys traveling and spending time with his wife and daughter.


Editorial Review:


"Commissar: A Novel of Civil War Russia" by D.V. Chernov is a captivating novel that

explores the tumult and complexity of the Russian Civil War, presenting strong characters

and profound internal conflicts. The story is well-documented and provides a vivid picture of

the chaos and uncertainties that marked that historical period.

Set against the backdrop of violence and radical social changes following the Bolshevik

Revolution, the novel's narrator immerses us in the lives of its characters through their

journals and direct experiences, offering an intimate perspective on their personal and moral

struggles.


One of the quotes that illustrates the tension and charged atmosphere in the novel is from

the journal of Boris Savinkov: “The first shipment of dynamite arrived in Moscow last night.

Ninety pounds is not nearly enough, but it is a start. V. promised more next week. If he is

unable to deliver, we will have no other option but to manufacture the rest. I hope it does not

come to that – sourcing the materials is risky enough, never mind the process.For now, we

store it in the basement under G.’s office. I’ve forgotten the sweet smell nitroglycerin gives it.

And the headaches that come with it. Tomorrow, N.will have an update about the guns.” This

journal entry underscores the daily dangers and urgencies faced by the revolutionaries as

they fought for their cause.


D.V. Chernov manages to capture the essence of a tumultuous period in Russian history,

bringing to life the internal conflicts of his characters caught between loyalty, survival, and

ideals. The novel is not just a historical fresco but also a meditation on human nature and

the difficult choices people make in times of crisis. Set in the immediate aftermath of the

Russian Revolution of 1917, various factions vie for control over Russia's future. The

Bolsheviks, representatives of the emerging communist power, and the White forces,

supporters of the monarchy and other counter-revolutionary factions, clash in bloody battles

and political maneuvers. At the center are ordinary people striving for land ownership and

the right to choose their leaders, aspirations seemingly out of reach amidst the power

struggle.


Central characters like Boris Savinkov and Anna are meticulously drawn with psychological

complexity. Savinkov, a fighter for democracy and leader of the People's Union for the

Defense of Homeland and Freedom, employs terror as a means to combat tyranny, justifying

extreme violence in pursuit of freedom and democracy. The scene from his journal detailing

a terrorist attack on the Grand Duke of Moscow vividly illustrates the brutality of his methods

and his steadfast belief that only terror can eradicate tyranny. Anna, grappling with her own

moral and professional dilemmas, provides an insider's perspective into the Bolshevik

apparatus. The scene where she is summoned to Dzerzhinsky's office, the feared leader of

the Cheka, is notable for its depiction of tense atmosphere and internal intrigues within the

security apparatus. Dzerzhinsky, known as "Iron Felix," is portrayed as obsessively devoted

to his cause, exemplifying the dedication and rigors of revolutionary life. Another significant

character, Dora Kaplan, stoically accepts her fate in prison, reflecting on her life and crimes.

Through these multiple perspectives, Chernov succeeds in capturing the complexity and

nuances of the Russian Revolution, where loyalties and identities are constantly shifting.

The novel deeply explores the geopolitical context of post-revolutionary Russia, highlighting

the intricate involvement of both foreign and domestic forces in the civil war. From British

and Japanese Allied troops to various White armies and the Czechoslovak Legion, Chernov

underscores the chaos and complexity of the times. The author masterfully blends personal

narrative with major historical events, creating an authentic tableau of a divided and

tumultuous Russia.


The novel continues with a tense scene where a convoy speeds through Moscow towards

the Kremlin, illuminated by headlights and guarded by armed soldiers. The atmosphere is

grim, reflected in Sergei's distant gaze, a central character grappling with moral and

emotional dilemmas. He and his team, including Anna, head to an apartment where they find

Lockhart, the British consul, in a state of confusion and irritation, evidently under the

influence of alcohol. Sergei's interrogation reveals tensions between the Soviet government

and foreign agents, highlighting backstage complicity and betrayals during the revolution.

Lockhart, caught in the midst of an assassination plot, vehemently denies direct involvement,

but his reactions and hesitations betray him. In a fit of rage, Sergei loses his composure for

the first time in front of Anna, underscoring the pressure and frustration felt by those striving

to stabilize the new Soviet regime. The atmosphere of distrust and danger is heightened by

the characters' reflections on their own actions and motivations. Sergei and Anna discuss

the perpetual threat posed by Western support for counter-revolutionary forces, illustrating

the moral difficulties and dilemmas in defending the revolution. Their conversation is

interrupted by overwhelming feelings of loss and grief, as well as the necessity to continue

the fight.


An essential aspect of the novel is its realistic portrayal of characters and the circumstances

they face. William, a notable protagonist, is an American who arrives in Petrograd and

spends his first week as a driver for Robins. This experience is not just about driving but

represents a profound lesson about the government and infrastructure of Russia: „From the

very first day, William realized that the task of driving was not at all about driving. It was

actually Robins’ way of tutoring him on the ins and outs of this country’s government and

infrastructure.”This sentence highlights Robins' subtle method of instruction and William's

desire to gain a deeper understanding of the country's realities.


In parallel, the novel explores Anna's life and her tense relationship with her family. Anna, a

supporter of the revolution, justifies her choice to work for the Cheka to her parents in an

intense and emotional scene. “I don’t work for the Cheka, Father – I am the Cheka! Because

someone has to be. Someone has to protect the people and their future because your

generation did not care to.”This statement reflects Anna's determination and deep

convictions, as well as the generational and ideological conflict dividing her family.

The novel unabashedly explores the brutality of the civil war. A pivotal moment is the

encounter between Anna and Makhno in a stark room adorned with a black flag and a

strategic map. Makhno, charismatic and unpredictable, pours tea from a chipped samovar,

adding authenticity to the scene. Their tense discussion, where Anna exposes Reilly's plans

and Makhno evaluates the risks of an ambush, creates an atmosphere of uncertainty.

Makhno's decision to assist, but with specific conditions, underscores the complexity of

alliances during the civil war. One of the most memorable scenes is the attack on the train,

where Chernov vividly describes the confrontation between Makhno's troops and the forces

of the White Army. William, Anna's American partner, plays a crucial role in the plan to

neutralize the train's artillery. The fight, intense and brutal, captures the chaos and horror of

military attack, showcasing Chernov's mastery in depicting action scenes and military

planning.


As Germany collapses under revolts and armistice discussions, British government support

for intervention in Russia becomes increasingly uncertain. In England, fear of Bolshevism

grows, and Downing Street commits to defeating communism at its source in Russia.

However, ministerial incompetence and political maneuvering further complicate the

situation. Within this context, the work also explores an international perspective, highlighting

the diplomatic efforts of figures like Raymond Robins, who establishes communication

channels with Soviet leaders. This complex dynamic is amplified by accounts of the

challenges faced by secret agents and diplomats involved in this backstage struggle.

The novel concludes on a reflective note, illustrating the desperation and hopes of the

characters through a letter from Masha to Anna, adding a personal touch to a story marked

by historical tumult. This letter brings a note of humanity and vulnerability, showing that

beyond ideological and political conflicts, there are also personal stories of sacrifice and

search for hope.


"Commissar: A Novel of Civil War Russia" is not just a chronicle of a tumultuous period in

Russian history but also a profound meditation on human nature in times of crisis. D.V.

Chernov skillfully blends historical facts with fiction, offering a compelling narrative rich in

meaning that resonates with history enthusiasts and readers of political thrillers alike.

Through his complex characters and captivating intrigues, Chernov provides readers with a

detailed and empathetic look at individual tragedies and triumphs amidst an epic struggle,

with each scene laden with significance and tension, keeping the reader on edge until the

last page.


"Commissar: A Novel of Civil War Russia" offers a deep and nuanced perspective on a

critical period in Russian history, exploring the human and moral complexity of its characters.

It is essential reading for those interested in Russian history and the human dynamics in a

context of intense conflict, concluding with a note of tension and anticipation that suggests

the conflict is far from over. Through its complex characters and well-documented narrative,

Chernov captures the essence of a turbulent period, delivering not only a gripping story but

also a meditation on the price of freedom and the struggle for power


*****


“Commissar” by D.V. Chernov receives 4 stars from The Historical Fiction Company


 

To have your historical novel editorially reviewed and/or enter the HFC Book of the Year contest, please visit www.thehistoricalfictioncompany.com/book-awards/award-submission





Comments


bottom of page